Jump to content
CrazyBoards.org

CookieN

Does the stage of your life in which you get ill determines your prognosis?

Recommended Posts

Does the stage of life in which you get ill determines your prognosis and course of the illness? For example a person who gets ill after graduating from college and working several years will be more equipped to face life than a person who got ill and never worked (getting ill in the college stage of life or before)??

Edited by CookieN
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As far as I know prognosis can differ drastically from person to person but some illnesses more commonly appear at the same time of life. Some people are diagnosed much younger, but bipolar and schizoaffective and schizophrenia all tend to appear in late adolescence. I was diagnosed at 19. Some illnesses are more severe than others but it can differ from case to case. For example, schizophrenia is considered to have a worse prognosis than schizoaffective which is considered to have a worse prognosis than bipolar. BUT that can be different for different people. Some people experience treatment resistance and thus a person with schizophrenia who is not treatment resistant might have a better prognosis than someone with bipolar who is.

I do not think it matters what time of life you were diagnosed at when it comes to determining how serious an illness is. Not only that, people who can hold a job are not necessarily better off than people who can't. Suicide is still a risk for people who can hold a job. For instance, I haven't been able to work most of my illness, but I do not consider myself a suicide risk. My grandfather who held a respectable position as a surgeon and seemingly was fine, he killed himself at 49 years old. People would not have considered him to be seriously ill from outward appearances. 

I guess what I'm saying is prognosis is different for everyone. 

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, saintalto said:

As far as I know prognosis can differ drastically from person to person but some illnesses more commonly appear at the same time of life. Some people are diagnosed much younger, but bipolar and schizoaffective and schizophrenia all tend to appear in late adolescence. I was diagnosed at 19. Some illnesses are more severe than others but it can differ from case to case. For example, schizophrenia is considered to have a worse prognosis than schizoaffective which is considered to have a worse prognosis than bipolar. BUT that can be different for different people. Some people experience treatment resistance and thus a person with schizophrenia who is not treatment resistant might have a better prognosis than someone with bipolar who is.

I do not think it matters what time of life you were diagnosed at when it comes to determining how serious an illness is. Not only that, people who can hold a job are not necessarily better off than people who can't. Suicide is still a risk for people who can hold a job. For instance, I haven't been able to work most of my illness, but I do not consider myself a suicide risk. My grandfather who held a respectable position as a surgeon and seemingly was fine, he killed himself at 49 years old. People would not have considered him to be seriously ill from outward appearances. 

I guess what I'm saying is prognosis is different for everyone. 

What if we do not compare one person with another but compare a person with himself/herself? Would the prognosis of the illnesss change if the same person got ill during college years vs after working for many years? Would the person be more equipped to face life challenges?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, notloki said:

What if we don't play what if ?

I second.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/26/2019 at 7:15 PM, Will said:
On 10/26/2019 at 7:08 PM, notloki said:

What if we don't play what if ?

I second.  

I third this.

That said, this question is addressed here. There's also research that suggests that the more mood episodes you have, the more likely you are to have them in the future. I think that suggests an answer about the hypothetical person as well.

There's more out there about this, particularly in academic and medical journals. Obviously not all of it will be true, or up-to-date, etc. Lots of articles can be found on pubmed.

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
28 minutes ago, 0112358 said:

I third this.

That said, this question is addressed here. There's also research that suggests that the more mood episodes you have, the more likely you are to have them in the future. I think that suggests an answer about the hypothetical person as well.

There's more out there about this, particularly in academic and medical journals. Obviously not all of it will be true, or up-to-date, etc. Lots of articles can be found on pubmed.

I agree with that. 

Phineas Gage is interesting.  Is your user name a mathematical progression?  If so, I'll try to figure it out.  If it's random I won't

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
47 minutes ago, Will said:

I agree with that. 

Phineas Gage is interesting.  Is your user name a mathematical progression?  If so, I'll try to figure it out.  If it's random I won't

appears to be fibonacci set

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, DogMan said:

appears to be fibonacci set

Yep - I once tried it when I was signing up for some account who knows where, and was really surprised when it wasn't taken, so I kept trying it... I don't think it has ever been unavailable, actually. Really weird. I mean, considering how the internet is global and so is math.

 

53 minutes ago, Will said:

I agree with that. 

Phineas Gage is interesting.  Is your user name a mathematical progression?  If so, I'll try to figure it out.  If it's random I won't

He is interesting. Also, part of his name is part of my name. So.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Without playing what if- all three of my child pdocs said younger is better- the first two quite emphatically. My current pdoc says that is a load of crap 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Similar Content

    • By CookieN
      Are dizziness and vertigo a warning sign that an episode is starting?
    • By kitties
      Hi, I am kitties.  I am a newbie here, but not to illness.  I have chronic pain 24/7 in my back and neck.
      Mentally....here are my diagnoses (got a second and third opinion....all objective and a consensus of the exact same diagnoses.)
      Bipolar 1 with psychosis, extreme, treatment resistant, rapid cycling.   Mixed features predominant.  Never had a remission to date...just a couple of weeks with my bipolar disorder.  “Normal” for a few weeks a couple of times per year.  No anxiety remission.
      OCD, GAD, Panic Disorder, Social Anxiety disorder, PTSD...I think that is everything.   Oh, I am significantly affected by a very strong dose of agoraphobia stemming from my PTSD and Panic Disorder.
      I have a great psychiatrist and I e been in treatment with him a since 2006.  I had a great therapist that had a co-transference issue and I ultimately ended my therapy with him. I have tried four therapists since firing the aforementioned therapist - but I unfortunately have lost faith in the process.
      I am a night owl by nature and it has really ramped up since being declared disabled in 2009/SSDI/cannot work.  I struggle with having a “routine,” although I have read that one with bipolar disorder tends to be more stable with a routine.  I’m easily overstimulated so I like the quiet and darkness..
      I know I have an eating disorder (anorexia, restricting type), but I politely yet firmly said I have had “eating issues” but I have no desire to “go there.”  My psychiatrist respects that although I am subject to a monthly weigh-in and I self-manage it.  
      I am currently relapsing right now, unfortunately. But, I have had it for so many years that I know at what weight my body and mind take a turn for the worst.  And I have to rein it back in and stop losing (meaning eat more).  I’ll never seek treatment as the recovery model, IMO, is ridiculous.  Kudos to those that have been able to “recover.”
      I take a bunch of meds, mainly psych meds  
      I like to read, Enjoy spending time with my boyfriend.  Internet.  I like learning things, I am currently and reading up on world history (pre-USA).  I keep up with psychology and sociology.
      Thanks for reading if you made it this far.
       
    • By candi71
      I am so very lost, angry, hurt, depressed, explosive, and drowning.  I was put on latuda or my bipolar and depression acting up...  I hate new meds for this reason.  I started having my ptsd dreams again, ate everything in site and craved sugar omg terribly,  have been depressed, cant color which i love to do, just wanna sleep, explosive anger, crying jags, hate life, nothing makes me happy, everything just sucks.  Im so angry cause i feel like i did before i went on any meds, 20yr ago.  
      Im so confused i just feel like im grasping at air.. I was in the er the other night and they basically sent me home after giving my dose of larzapam i didn't take in the afternoon cause i doesn't help.  My theory of   it is it didn't help before the latuda what is gonna make it work coming off latuda or after off.. I remember why i drank now.. I didn't need to feel this then.. I want to drink so bad and wont cause I've been clean 6 yrs April will  be 7 and i worked to hard to get here and refuse to prove others right.  Im so so messed up i cant sleep cant watch TV cant color yet dont want to do any of the above either but if i dont sleep i hurt... has anyone felt this way..  It sux cause the battle to find meds to work will start tomorrow cause my liver doesn't process meds it flushes them out.. oh well sorry just needed to vent and hope someone can help
    • By CookieN
      Has anyone tried lysine with good results?
×
×
  • Create New...