Jump to content
CrazyBoards.org

Escitalopram vs Sertraline  

5 members have voted

  1. 1. Which one did you like more?

    • Escitalopram
      1
    • Sertraline
      3
    • equally good
      0
    • equally shitty
      1


Recommended Posts

Both are second-generation SSRIs, both exhibit minimal drug interactions via Cytochrome P450, both are the most prescribed SSRIs and are considered first line antidepressants. Who's been taking both and what were your experiences? (How did they compare to each other?). I am looking forward to read your experiences...

Which one did you like more?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Everyone has a different reaction to different meds, but say whatever you want about all SSRIs being the same - I'll never agree with this claim.

Twice on Sertraline, all dose range (50mg-300mg) worked great for mood, has some kind of energizing/calming effect. Something like a weak Ritalin-ish feel.

Escitalopram, once, low dose. Did nothing for my depression, if not making it worse... and killed my sex drive.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

escitalopram and zoloft were the first and second meds i tried, respectively.

i forget my dose of escitalopram, but it wasn't very high. it put me in a total fog. i was sleepy and not very present.

sertraline i think went up to 200 mg. it was good for energy and mood, but exacerbated my obsessive racing thoughts and made my anxiety worse. even with .5 mg risperidone added, i was still anxious with fast thoughts (not mania -- just good old GAD with a splash of obsessiveness). my pdoc took me off of it in exchange for something more sedating.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Major differences, sertraline tends to be stimulating where escitalopram tends to be more calming. Sertraline is more likely comparatively in my experience to cause diarrhea. However it was less likely to cause anhedonia. I only ever took sertraline at 25mg and 50mg successfully, 75mg started to go in the wrong direction. Hard to explain but not the point of this post. Escitalopram ever only took 10mg but that was quite sufficient for my depression and it works quickly. Problem is it makes you feel like a complacent slug after long-term use and caused more anhedonia than sertraline as I said before.

Edited by browri
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • By Riverkhamsin
      So, I'm bipolar, type 2. I tend to live in depression and only occasionally get the kind of manic you could replicate with a good caffeine high. I've been on Sertraline for over a year. I can't actually remember how long. I'm currently at 150 mg once daily, and I have been since October of last year. I also take Trileptal, recently reduced from 300 mg twice a day to 150 mg twice a day at my request. I requested the decrease in Trileptal because my pdoc said that it was the more likely cause of my persistent brain fog and exhaustion. I've been on that for a long time. 4 years? 5? Around there. The reduction in Trileptal doesn't seem to have made any difference.
      I can't think straight anymore. I'm making mistakes at work, and my last mistake caused a minor injury. I'm tired from the moment I wake up until I finally pass out at the end of the day. But getting to sleep is difficult. No matter how tired I am, it takes forever to sleep. And then I tend to sleep lightly. I'm forgetting things. Important things. But not interpersonal things- just work things. I can remember the details about a coworker's date last week or what my boyfriend said about something two months ago, but conversations my boss has had with me about what she wants? Gone. Either I'm being gaslit (possible, she's known to think she had conversations with people that never happened, but this is happening more and more often) or I've got some big holes opening up in my head. And it's concerning.
      One of my coworkers is also bipolar, and when we talked, she suggested that it's from having been on sertraline for as long as I have. Anyone had that happen? On sertraline or anything else?
      I also take allegra for my allergies, vitamin b complex as well as a vitamin d supplement. Aside from a vitamin D deficiency, my bloodwork always comes back damn near perfect, though with COVID I haven't gotten it done this year. I tend to be very very sensitive to sedating medications- klonopin and benadryl both leave me groggy for at least a day afterwards and when I was on venlafaxine I couldn't stay awake. Wellbutrin xl gave me massive stomach cramps, and I got the lamotrigine rash.
    • By Skeletor
      Why do strong SRIs (serotonin reuptake inhibitors) often cause / induce apathy, indifference and laziness? Maybe not in everyone, but it's one of the most common complaints. I regularly read about it on the internet. I myself was affected by it.
      My questions would be:
      1.) What causes it?
      2.) Were you affected?
      3.) Did you successfully get rid of these specific side effects? If so, how so?
      4.) Further comments regarding that "phenomenon"?
    • By Skeletor
      Sertraline standalone makes many people somewhat apathetic, indifferent and unmotivated, and that's why doctor Gillman suggests augmenting it with Nortriptyline OR alternatively taking Clomipramine standalone for the full SNRI effect...
      Did anyone here try both combos? I am getting back on antidepressants and not sure how to proceed... but if I had to choose, I would preferably go for one of the two possibilities.
    • By Catwoman
      I'm tapering off clomipramine, right now I'm down to 75 mg.
       
      I've been on it for almost a year, but I'm not impressed with the results. I was hoping it would work better than my last two SSRI's (which seemed to do the best job when I took them for the first time) but I can't go higher than 100 mg because of side effects.

      A few months ago risperidone was added to the clomipramine. I'm on 1 mg a day. I've seen some improvement, but I can still have difficult days or even weeks where I'm having too much intrusive thoughts (or thought, since it's been only one thought which bothers me). 

      I've had good results from fluvoxamine and escitalopram, but both pooped out. Maybe clomipramine had pooped out too.

      According to my pdoc, taking risperidone as a monotherapy won't have much effect. And with OCD, an antipsychotic is mainly added as an augment treatment.

      So what to do next?
×
×
  • Create New...